Best Thanksgiving Pies by the Slice in NYC 2025By Angelica Malin

Thanksgiving isn’t complete without a slice of pie, but you don’t have to commit to a whole one to sample the city’s best. Whether you’re looking for gluten-free, classic, or totally innovative flavours, NYC bakeries have your dessert plans covered. Here’s where to grab the best Thanksgiving pies by the slice in New York this year:

1. Best Pumpkin Pie in New York: Kerber’s Farm

A Long Island staple with a Manhattan outpost, Kerber’s Farm offers ultra-flaky, buttery pies in classic flavours. Try their perfectly spiced Pumpkin Pie or gooey Pecan Slice – each one tastes like Thanksgiving in a bite.

2. Best Chocolate Pecan Tart: Citarella

If you’re shopping for groceries and want dessert sorted, Citarella’s mini pumpkin pies are the ultimate shortcut. No mess, just seasonal flavour – these single-serving pies are a festive grab-and-go treat.​

3. Best Seasonal Cakes: Eataly

For anyone craving variety, Eataly brings its Italian flair to the Thanksgiving table. Choose from an array of individual cakes and festive bakes, perfect for mixed gatherings or anyone whose dessert loyalty changes by the day.​

4. Best Classic Pecan Pie: Martha’s Country Bakery

A NYC institution, Martha’s is famous for its generous pie slices and classic flavours. Their Pecan Pie delivers everything you want: nutty richness and just the right amount of sweetness. It’s a must-try for anyone seeking tradition.​

@jellymalin

Replying to @emerzzzzzz Here’s everywhere you get can an individual pie in NYC for Thanksgiving 🥧🍂 Featuring @eataly @Citarella Gourmet Market @Magnolia Bakery @Breads Bakery @Kerber’s Farm @pies’n’thighs Save this list! Best whole pies: @Angelica Malin – NYC Lifestyle  #thanksgiving #pie #NYCfood #thanksgivingNYC #NYCdesserts

♬ Little Things – Adrián Berenguer

5. Best Overall Individual Pies: Breads Bakery

Don’t overlook Breads, where the renowned babka is rivaled only by their Thanksgiving Pecan Pie. Expect a crisp crust, perfectly caramelised filling, and the kinds of flavours that feel instantly nostalgic.​

6. Best Handmade Pumpkin Pie: Petee’s Pie Company

Petee’s keeps the craft of pie-making alive with outstanding ingredients and next-level crusts. Their Pumpkin Pie is city-famous for a reason: every bite is smooth, spiced, and simply satisfying.​

7. Best Pumpkin Cheesecake: Magnolia Bakery

Magnolia is much more than banana pudding. Their seasonal offering, Pumpkin Pudding, is creamy, comforting, and layers everything you love about Thanksgiving desserts in one cup.​

8. Best Gluten-Free Pecan Pie: Noglu 

For the gluten-free crowd, Noglu’s Chocolate Pecan Mini Pie is a decadent, safe bet that never feels like a compromise. Real chocolate and crunchy nuts make for a mini pie you’ll remember.

9. Best Gluten-Free Apple Pie: Little Pie Company

Their Blueberry Apple Crumb Pie, available gluten-free, is perfect if you’re seeking a fruity (and crowd-pleasing) twist on tradition. Every forkful is packed with berries and spice, finished with a crumbly, satisfying topping.​

10. Best Sweet Potato Pie: Pies N Thighs

Finally, for something different, head to Pies N Thighs for Sweet Potato Pie. This Southern-inspired classic is silky, sweet, and sings of cinnamon and nutmeg – heartwarming in every sense.