Best Thanksgiving Pies to Order in New York 2025By Angelica Malin
Thanksgiving in New York means one thing: pie season. Whether you’re into the classics or craving something a little more inventive, the city’s best bakeries are delivering the goods – flaky crusts, sweet fillings and the kind of desserts that make you forget about turkey entirely. From pumpkin perfection to maple-pecan masterpieces, here are the best Thanksgiving pies in NYC to order this year:
@jellymalin Where to get the best Thanksgiving pies in New York 2025! Who wants pie? Got any favourites in the city? 🥧 #thanksgiving #nycdesserts #nycfood #thanksgivingdinner #newyorkcity
Best Thanksgiving Pies in NYC: Quirky Pies
What: We love Breads Bakery and they make some of the best Thanksgiving pies in NYC. The cult-status bakery’s babka pie is a Thanksgiving twist on their iconic chocolate babka – a swirl of rich cocoa filling tucked into buttery pastry. Equal parts nostalgic and inventive.
The Lowdown: Layers of chocolate decadence meet a crisp crust – soft and doughy, with a little crunch. It’s the showstopper your Thanksgiving table deserves.
Price & Address: $46 – Multiple locations including Union Square and Lincoln Center – breadsbakery.com
2. Supermoon Bakery: Thanksgiving Pie
What: Known for its viral croissants and creative desserts, Supermoon’s Thanksgiving Pie is as theatrical as it is tasty. Expect intricate layers, chocolatey flavours and an show-stopping design.
The Lowdown: This isn’t just dessert — it’s a centerpiece. The pie features a Chocolate Pie Crust Base, Pumpkin Spice Caramel, Roasted Pumpkin Mousse and so much more.
Price & Address: $70 – 120 Rivington St, LES – supermoonbakehouse.com
3. Poppy’s Bakery: Salted Bourbon Pecan Tart
What: Poppy’s is a woman-owned hospitality brand born out of a passion for serving seasonal, delicious food and building community. A buttery tart shell filled with toasted pecans, dark sugar and a whisper of smoky bourbon. A modern classic in the making.
The Lowdown: Rich, gooey, and just boozy enough – this one’s made for those who like their Thanksgiving pies with a grown-up twist.
Price & Address: $45 – 243 Degraw St, Brooklyn – poppysbrooklyn.com
4. Librae Bakery: Salted Maple Pecan & Date Pie
What: From the Bahraini-inspired bakery comes a holiday pie packed with Middle Eastern flavour and NYC edge. Sticky dates, salted maple and buttery pecans unite in perfect harmony.
The Lowdown: It’s sweet but balanced, familiar yet fresh – the kind of pie that sparks conversation at the dessert table. They have already run out of pre-orders but you may be able to snag one on the day!
Price & Address: $42 – 35 Cooper Sq, East Village – libraebakery.com
Best Thanksgiving Pies in NYC: Traditional Pies
5. Little Pie Company: Pumpkin Pie
What: This Hell’s Kitchen landmark has been slinging perfect pies since the ’80s. Their pumpkin version remains a holiday go-to for good reason.
The Lowdown: Lightly spiced, perfectly creamy, and baked fresh daily – it’s New York’s most comforting slice of Thanksgiving nostalgia.
Price & Address: $48 – 424 W 43rd St, NYC – littlepiecompany.com
6. Peete’s Pies: Farm Fresh Pumpkin Pie
What: A true Thanksgiving essential. Handcrafted using local ingredients, Peete’s pumpkin pie embodies everything comforting about the holiday. This is one of the best pie shops in the city – you can’t go wrong with any of the pies here.
The Lowdown: Smooth, spiced pumpkin custard atop a golden, flaky crust – your grandmother would approve.
Price & Address: $45 – LES – peetespies.com
7. Épicerie Boulud: Pumpkin Pie
What: Daniel Boulud’s bakery takes pumpkin pie to Paris with a touch of French finesse. The filling is silky, the crust delicate, and the presentation elegant.
The Lowdown: For Thanksgiving hosts who want refinement with their whipped cream. Best paired with Champagne, obviously.
Price & Address: $55 – Multiple locations including Lincoln Center – epicerieboulud.com
8. Kerber’s Farm: Blueberry Traditional Pie
What: A humble yet beautifully executed pie, bursting with tart-sweet blueberries and home-baked charm. We love Kerber’s Farm for pies made with local, seasonal ingredients of the best quality.
The Lowdown: Proof that Thanksgiving pies don’t need pumpkin to please. Handmade on Long Island, a farmhouse favourite worth the trip.
Price & Address: $32 – 309 Main St, Huntington, NY and Bleeker Street – kerbersfarm.com
Best Thanksgiving Pies in NYC: Pecan Pies
9. Martha’s Country Bakery: Pecan Pie
What: A Queens favourite that nails comfort baking with big Southern flair. Their pecan pie is gooey, golden, and utterly nostalgic.
The Lowdown: A perfect balance of chewy, nutty, and sweet – we can’t get enough of the pecan pie at Martha’s and enjoy it year-round.
Price & Address: $43 – Locations across Queens & Williamsburg – marthascountrybakery.com
10. Ole & Steen: Pumpkin and Chocolate Pecan Pie
What: A Scandinavian twist on a holiday staple. Ole & Steen’s version layers pumpkin and chocolate pecan for a flavour combo that’s rich yet sophisticated.
The Lowdown: Ideal for hosts who want a modern, minimalist pie moment.
Price & Address: $46 – Multiple NYC locations – oleandsteen.us
11. Four & Twenty Blackbirds: Bittersweet Chocolate Pecan Pie
What: Brooklyn’s most famous pie shop never misses. Their chocolate pecan pie adds cocoa depth to the classic nutty crowd-pleaser. Voted the best pie in all of America, have one bite and you’ll see why.
The Lowdown: Dark chocolate lovers, this one’s for you. A must-order for Thanksgiving in NYC.
Price & Address: $48 – 439 3rd Ave, Gowanus, Brooklyn – birdsblack.com
Wherever you order from this Thanksgiving, make pie your priority. New York’s bakeries are baking up something for every taste – from classic pumpkin to curious chocolate pecan. Just don’t forget the whipped cream.
